Typically, I only have three pet peeves, when it comes to a lady's feet...
1.) Cannot be tore up, beat up, and shredded, because of some ridiculous obsession with ill fitting, agony inducing, "pretty" shoes. The breaking of this rule is unforgivable.
2.) Overly veiny is "yuck." For instance, Jennifer Aniston has great shape, great tan, well pedicured feet, but they're so veiny, they look like an interstate map. ... Just not my thing.
3.) I don't really pay attention to shoe size or how long her feet are. I do pay attention to how wide a woman's for is. (I'll gladly take a long, slender Size 9 over a fat, wideload Size 6, any day.) Wide feet = Man feet.
looking at her 'looking down foot selfies', I can see why she would think that. Structurally, her feet are very nice -- good arch. but her toenails are inconsistent from foot to foot, and her 2nd to last toes have a strange bend to them.