No, as you said, it's your OPINION... you're stating 'facts' as you see them and apply them to your personal tastes. One cannot apply 'facts' to the subject of beauty, which is subjective for each individual.
"De gustibus non est disputandum."
1½-2 stars means, "Almost as bad as Oprah." Go look at her gallery, and June Shannon's, then come back here and tell us these are close to those. Also, you only mentioned toes, not other parts of her foot, like her lovely arch and instep.
That being said, you'd be simply amazed how many dudes here just LOVE the Morton's Toe (short great toe/long second toe). I do not.